Nov 12 · 8 min

Prix Fixe Near Union Square: What Each Set Menu Includes

By Jules Bennett · November 12, 2026 · 8 min read

Direct answer

Prix fixe near Union Square at eight Italian restaurants, from a $29 weekday lunch to a $110 pasta tasting: what each set menu includes and who can order it.

Olio e Più’s $29 weekday lunch is the lowest of the eight Italian prix fixe menus printed near Union Square, and Rezdôra’s $110 regional pasta tasting is the highest, with Paul & Jimmy’s at $35, Massara from $40 and Carlotto at $65 between them. Tarallucci e Vino, Zero Otto Nove and Da Andrea list theirs for groups, from 8 guests at two of them and 10 at the third. Every price, hour and party-size rule below was read from the restaurant’s own site in October 2026.

Eight set menus near Union Square, and who can order each

The menus any table can order come first, then the group menus, each half cheapest first. Olio e Più, Massara, Carlotto and Rezdôra’s menu page do not print “per person”, so those figures are read per diner. Totals below leave out drinks, tax and tip.

Per person Restaurant Address Who can order it Key detail
$29 Olio e Più East Village 106 3rd Avenue Regular tables, not group bookings Starter and main, Monday to Friday, 11am to 4pm
$35 Paul & Jimmy’s 123 East 18th Street No party-size rule printed Appetizer, entrée and dessert, Monday to Friday, noon to 3pm
$40 for two courses, $50 for three Massara 913 Broadway No party-size rule printed Lunch Menu tab; every dish also sold a la carte
$65 Carlotto 100 East 19th Street No party-size rule printed Dinner, daily; supplements on selected dishes
$110 on the menu page, $98 on the FAQ page Rezdôra 27 East 20th Street Any table, if everyone takes it Pasta tasting, dinner only
$30 brunch, $42 lunch, $65 dinner Tarallucci e Vino 15 East 18th Street Parties of 8 or more Prix fixe required from 8 guests
$65 brunch, 58 dollars lunch, $85 dinner Da Andrea 35 West 13th Street Event deck, 8 guests minimum Three courses, drinks not included
$75 Zero Otto Nove 15 West 21st Street Groups of 10 or more Five courses with coffee, dessert and soft drinks

Left out of the table: Massara’s Chef’s Table, a four-course seasonal prix fixe booked by inquiry form with no price printed, and Paul & Jimmy’s Event Menu tab, for parties of 20 to 70 guests.

Can a table of two order the prix fixe, or is it for groups?

It varies by restaurant. Olio e Più says its lunch prix fixe is “available for regular dining only” and “does not apply to private events or group bookings”, without saying at what headcount a booking becomes a group. Paul & Jimmy’s, Massara and Carlotto print no party-size rule on theirs, and Rezdôra asks only that the full table take part. Tarallucci e Vino goes the other way: “For parties of 8 or more guests, a prix fixe menu is required.” Its page does not say whether a smaller party can order one.

Read by headcount, the rule is short:

  • A table of two: Olio e Più or Paul & Jimmy’s (weekday lunch), Massara (lunch), Carlotto (dinner) or Rezdôra’s tasting, if both diners order it.
  • Six guests: Tarallucci e Vino asks for a card on file and applies a $35-per-person fee under its cancellation policy.
  • Eight guests: Tarallucci e Vino’s prix fixe becomes required and Da Andrea’s event menus open up (its deck allows up to 30 in Greenwich Village).
  • Ten guests: Zero Otto Nove’s menu opens. Massara’s pages differ: its Chef’s Table page says seven to ten guests, but its About page sends groups of 10 or more to a private dining form.

Private rooms and other group rules are in Restaurants Near Union Square for Groups: Where to Book.

Prix fixe dinner near Union Square: $65 to $110 per person

Four menus are labeled for dinner, from $65 to $110 per person. Carlotto’s and Tarallucci e Vino’s are both $65, though only Tarallucci’s is headed for parties of 8 or more. Da Andrea’s event dinner is $85. Rezdôra’s tasting is $110 on its menu page and $98 per guest on its FAQ page; both pages give the wine pairing as $90, and neither explains the gap. Zero Otto Nove’s group menu is $75, but its page does not say which meal it covers.

For two diners, Carlotto comes to 130 dollars before supplements and Rezdôra to 220 dollars at $110 a head or 196 dollars at $98, before any pairing. Eight guests come to 520 dollars at Tarallucci e Vino’s dinner prix fixe and 680 at Da Andrea’s; ten come to 650 at Tarallucci e Vino, 750 at Zero Otto Nove and 850 at Da Andrea, before Da Andrea’s minimum spend. For a citywide comparison, La Superlativa’s Multi-Course Italian Dinner NYC: 6 Restaurants Worth Booking covers six restaurants.

Do Italian restaurants near Union Square have a prix fixe lunch?

Five menus are labeled for lunch, and the two cheapest run on weekdays only. Olio e Più lists a Lunch Prix Fixe at $29, Monday to Friday, 11am to 4pm, 11 dollars below Massara’s $40 for two courses. Paul & Jimmy’s lists $35 for an appetizer, entrée and dessert, Monday to Friday, noon to 3pm, the lowest of the three-course lunches: Massara’s are $50 and Da Andrea’s group lunch is 58 dollars. Paul & Jimmy’s site says new owners took over in 2026, so confirm the menu. Tarallucci e Vino’s $42 lunch is for groups.

Massara’s Lunch Menu tab does not say which days it runs; its hours list daytime service Tuesday to Sunday and dinner only on Monday. Because every selection is sold prix fixe or a la carte, the set price is not always a discount. The $9 ciabatta with the $26 paccheri pomodoro is 35 dollars a la carte, 5 dollars under the two-course price, while the $29 Classico Antipasto with the $42 half branzino is 71 dollars. The page does not say whether dessert or a side counts as a course.

Afternoon hours are in restaurants open between lunch and dinner near Union Square; a la carte pasta prices are in Cheap Eats Near Union Square: What Pasta Really Costs.

What does a prix fixe menu include at Italian restaurants near Union Square?

Olio e Più East Village. A starter (bruschetta al pomodoro, insalata di spinaci or caponatina siciliana) and a main (spaghetti alla carbonara, polpette della nonna or scaloppina al limone); no dessert is listed.

Paul & Jimmy’s. Lunch only: one appetizer, one entrée (penne primavera, eggplant parmigiana, chicken francese or grilled salmon among them) and one dessert, with coffee, tea or espresso among the choices.

Massara. Antipasto, primi, secondi and dolci sections drawn from the lunch menu, from pizzette and baby gem to paccheri pomodoro and half branzino.

Carlotto. One antipasti, one pasta, risotto or secondi, and one dolce, from 5pm daily.

Rezdôra. A regional pasta tasting at dinner only; neither page lists the courses. A vegetarian tasting is available, and guests should allow two hours.

Tarallucci e Vino. Dinner is one antipasti (burrata, Cesare or tortino di melanzane), one secondi (spaghetti, rigatoni with short rib ragù, cacio e pepe, milanese or filetto di branzino) and one dolci (tiramisù, chocolate mousse cake or affogato). Lunch is antipasti and secondi only. Brunch is a pastry and a coffee drink, then one plate.

Zero Otto Nove. Five courses: a taste of pizza, antipasti, primi, secondi and a dolce. The price covers coffee, dessert and soft drinks; the page prints that tax, gratuity and beverages (bottled water, wine, beer and liquor) are not included. Groups schedule by phone at (212) 242-0899.

Da Andrea. Three courses, one choice from each, at brunch, lunch and dinner. Lunch carries supplements of $6 and $9 on selected dishes. The deck requires a minimum spend, and the final bill carries taxes and 20% gratuity.

What counts as a prix fixe here

The eight are Italian restaurants around the square whose own websites print a set-price menu with a price; this is not a census. Menus shown only as images could not be quoted, and holiday menus are left out. Da Andrea’s deck prints its lunch price with a full-width dollar sign, so it is written as 58 dollars here. Confirm the price and the party-size rule when booking.

Frequently asked questions

Which restaurants near Union Square have a prix fixe menu?

As of October 2026, eight Italian restaurants near Union Square print a prix fixe: Olio e Più East Village, Paul & Jimmy’s, Massara, Carlotto, Rezdôra, Tarallucci e Vino, Da Andrea and Zero Otto Nove. The first five print no group requirement; the last three list theirs for groups.

Is Rezdôra’s pasta tasting $110 or $98?

Both figures appear on Rezdôra’s own site, as of October 2026. Its menu page lists the regional pasta tasting at $110, and its FAQ page says $98 per guest at dinner service. Both give the optional wine pairing as $90 and say the full table must take part, so confirm the figure when booking.

Do the prix fixe menus near Union Square include drinks?

Not entirely. Zero Otto Nove’s $75 group menu covers coffee, dessert and soft drinks, but not bottled water, wine, beer, liquor, tax or gratuity. Da Andrea’s three-course menu “does not include any beverages”, and Rezdôra lists a $90 wine pairing as an option beside its tasting.

Does Carlotto’s prix fixe carry supplements?

Yes. Carlotto’s $65 three-course dinner prix fixe, available daily, carries supplements on selected dishes, from $7 on the yellowtail crudo to $35 on the veal chop parmesan and the tagliata di manzo. The three courses are one antipasti, one pasta, risotto or secondi, and one dolce.

↑ Back to the board

Get the service alerts

One email when a new post pulls into the station — lunch intel, aperitivo timing, and downtown plans. No delays, no spam.

Weekly at most · unsubscribe anytime